Tags
(satire)
In an effort to save money and simplify the test used to assess whether people on sickness or disability benefits are fit enough to work, the Department of Work and Pensions has decided to reduce the questionnaire to just one yes or no question – ‘Are you alive?‘
But according to experts, the simplified one question computer test, which the government pays French IT firm ATOS £100 million a year to administer, still gets the assessments wrong 70% of the time.
A spokesperson for ATOS explained why, despite extensive training in box ticking, their assessors still may face difficulties knowing which box to tick:
No test is perfect and although our box tickers are experts on ticking boxes, we admit we might still be getting it wrong sometimes. For example, if you ask someone the question “are you alive” and the person answers “no” it’s obvious which box to tick but if for example, an assessor receives an answer such as “barely”, which sometimes happens, it’s not as easy as you think to decide which box to tick.
The government denies it has set quotas whereby ATOS must find 70% of dead people fit for employment whether they are able to work or not.
However, a spokesperson for the Department of Work and Pensions explained that the government was keen to make sure anyone claiming to be dead was genuinely unable to work:
If the person is clearly dead, then they can claim incapacity benefit but it’s possible a certain percentage of people who claim they are dead may be swinging the led and we want to make sure they really are unable to work.
The government has also promised to weed out any people who may be technically deceased but despite their condition are still eligible for work. The DWP spokesperson explained:
You only need to look at Rupert Murdoch to see someone who looks like he’s dead but in fact is most likely alive. Allegations that he’s a special case because he is actually a member of the undead whose aim is to sap the will to live out of every living being on Earth, have absolutely no basis in fact. Probably.
.
Please feel free to comment – you don’t need to register and I’m extremely minimal with the moderatiing – so fire away:
Dan Bun Middleton said:
ha ha ha
LikeLike
Dan Bun Middleton said:
would not supprise me if they did do some thing as stupid
LikeLike
warriet said:
ATOS pointed out the ability to distinguish between dead and alive was not part of its original brief, that the failure must lie with the DWP referral mechanism. Remedy would be made by the more thorough selection of assessment staff. While finding capable people would be very difficult. the extra cost would be borne by the DWP whose original specification was clearly inadequate, that the ATOS shareholders and bones recipients would not be harmed. The DWP said that this was normal and that any extra costs would be within the normal range of IT budget overruns.
LikeLike
wisden said:
“Fit for active service” by George Grosz, 1918
http://www.moma.org/collection/object.php?object_id=35441
LikeLike
Tom Pride said:
Great link – just shows there’s nothing new under the sun when it comes to what Machiavelian methods governments will use to get their way…
LikeLike
Tom Pride said:
This is not entirely satire. There are cases of people being assessed as ‘fit to work’ who have died literally days later:
http://diaryofabenefitscrounger.blogspot.com/2011/05/3-claimants-die-after-being-found-fit.html
LikeLike
warriet said:
I Know. ATOS/DWP/IDS have devised a breathtaking Catch 22 whereby benefit will be stopped if you do not get to an assessment centre and if you do make it there you will be deemed to be capable of some sort of work.
LikeLike
Rebecca Ashling said:
I bet that the government is hiring necromancers to raise the dead as we speak.
LikeLike
syzygysue said:
ATOS was brought in to deliberately marginalise medical opinion. As you say Tom, this article is barely satire. My MP relative has had terminally ill cancer patients, classified as fit for work, only 6 weeks from their death. The Welfare reforms bills should rank highly amongst New Labour’s shameful acts.
LikeLike
wisden said:
Talking of Machiavelli and ME/CFS
http://thekafkapandemic.blogspot.com/2011/11/machiavellian-approach.html
LikeLike
Tom Pride said:
The ‘failure’ of the ATOS testing is not incompetence. Unfortunately, if anyone is expecting the reviews to change anything they are going to be disappointed.
LikeLike
bridget price said:
Why should being dead be an obsticle to work? Clearly, well motivated mourners Should stop blubbering and put deceased relatives to work as fertilizer, or burgler deterents.
A few corpses in the House of Commons might liven things up.
Come to that reports from Atossers are so falacious that they could be prewritten and the dead could take the place of the assessors. The cost of additional embalming fluid could surely be off set against a reduction in provision of coffee?
And as Rebecca says necromancy is the way to go.
LikeLike
Tom Pride said:
Absolutely Bridget. It’s about time these so-called dead people stopped expecting the rest of us to support them while they lie around in cemeteries doing nothing.
LikeLike
Pingback: The ConDem Government’s Best Satirical Moments Of 2011 « Pride's Purge
Emma said:
Being dead is no excuse! http://welfarejustice.org.uk/rather-bad-cartoon/
LikeLike
Pingback: Support The Spartacus Report – be part of an on-line and media campaign against the government…starting today. « Pride's Purge
Mike Moreton said:
This article may have some basis in fact. After all, we only have to look at the house of lords….
LikeLike
syb said:
i have a back prob paralysis no reflex action, right leg slashed feeling. pain right side chest. pain neck leg back ankle toes. I am sent back to work 30hrs strenously cleaning offices that are cutting down time given to work wont perfection someone should inform them not possible. I have been asked to pay £70 rent out of an allowance of £67 and they insist that it is right
LikeLike
bridget price said:
Unbelievable you poor sod! We are soon going to have to just kill the rich and eat them or burn them for fuel. Oh but with your back you won’t be much good at holding a pitchfork will you! Sorry mate slavery ’till you die. On the plus side with minus £3 a week you will actually die of hunger fairly soon.
By the way whilst at work do not do anything that hurts or would cause you to be in pain later, so, turn up, hold your mop (limply) or lie prone on the floor in a comfortable position. If questioned explain that: you have managed to bend and pick up a piece of paper (or mop), managed to get to the premises, managed to dress yourself. You are now not able to do any more but that should not constitute a problem because ATOS say that is all work entails so you have met all the requirements for work.
LikeLike
Tom Pride said:
Good advice.
LikeLike
Pingback: Scientists Confirm Deniers Were Right – Global Disability Is A Hoax! « Pride's Purge
Pingback: Workfare = Workhouse? « Pride's Purge
Pingback: Grayling – Benefit sanctions to be dropped. Even though they don’t exist. « Pride's Purge
Pingback: Millions of sick & disabled to be injected into economy to stimulate growth « Pride's Purge
Natasha said:
Great piece Tom. This was one of your pieces from last year but you re tweeted it so I read it for the first time today . It’s a bit chilling really for me. I personally know someone who died of cancer 3 months after being found fit for work by ATOS.
Tom, you have a genius way with words and satire and I love you for it. It inspires me to be militant and try to fight this evil.
LikeLike
Tom Pride said:
Thanks Natasha. I know it’s a bit close to the knuckle but as you obviously know, it’s not far from the truth – unfortunately.
Evil’s the right word.
LikeLike
Pingback: IDS – government ministers just sit around drinking coffee all day « Pride's Purge
Pingback: Government Retirement Age To Be Raised From 5 To 67 years « Pride's Purge
Pingback: Paralympic Athletes Listed For Sale on eBay by Sponsor ATOS « Pride's Purge
Pingback: Unemployed Vie For Workfare Placements in NHS Hospital After Cameron Announces Vasectomy Operation There « Pride's Purge
Pingback: Jobcentre staff to encourage alcoholic jobseekers to seek treatment by starving them to death « Pride's Purge
Pingback: Toby Young – disabled children should be excluded from schools « Pride's Purge
Pingback: Exclusive: read an extract from Part 4 of the blockbuster trilogy – 50 Shades Of Grayling « Pride's Purge
Pingback: Police taser innocent samurai after mistaking him for a blind man « Pride's Purge
Ms Diseased said:
I died last week and I’m afraid to say that God also has a contract with ATOS… they sent me to Hell!
LikeLike
Ms Deceased said:
Oops, that should have Ms Deceased!
LikeLike
Tom Pride said:
Bloody ATOS seem to have a frigging contract with everyone.
LikeLike
Pingback: Emma Harrison: “Heartless taxpayers bullied me into paying myself £8.6m of their money” « Pride's Purge
Pingback: A Modest Proposal to Cut The Cost of Keeping the Unemployed Alive by Housing Them in Tesco! « Pride's Purge
Pingback: How Delboy hoodwinked ministers out of £300m – UPDATE « Pride's Purge
Pingback: Duncan Smith claims billions wasted on food by low-paid creates culture of dependency « Pride's Purge
Pingback: Jobless, futureless, discarded youths likely to feel a bit depressed sometimes, says study « Pride's Purge
fizzipus said:
Of course the dead can work. They are completely suited to being Tory MPs, a job which does not require a brain, a heart or a pulse.
LikeLike
Pingback: Admit it UK charities – you were conned by Cameron and his so-called ‘Big Society’ garbage « Pride's Purge
Pingback: Revealed – top Tory in child abuse allegations is Iain Duncan-Smith « Pride's Purge
Pingback: A4e paid over 45 million of taxpayers money – to give classes on using toilet paper « Pride's Purge
Pingback: Meet the activist stormtroopers standing up to government bullying and privatisation. Court interpreters! | Pride's Purge
Pingback: SERCO wins bid to run UK as Victorian theme park | Pride's Purge
Pingback: Jamie Oliver is right! A giant TV can feed a family of 4 for a week! | Pride's Purge